Limited Time Offer: Save 40% on PRO with code GOPRO2018 »

Real-World Education for Modern Marketers

Join Over 600,000 Marketing Professionals

Start here!
Text:  A A

In Search, Bigger Is Not Better

by   |    |  9,399 views

When a search engine founder like me hits out at Google, a global search engine with a reported $13.3 billion in ad revenue as of June 2007, some might call it envy of size and scale.

But business and professional users searching for work-related information on the Web will tell you, as a matter of online marketing fact, that bigger is definitely not better. They have experienced significant frustration in finding needed data through general search engines like Google and Yahoo.

A 2006 study by Outsell reported a 31.9 percent failure rate among business users when researching topics using the major search engines. A separate study from Convera shows that professionals in virtually every industry are having trouble finding important work-related information on the major search engines.

While frustrating for B2B players, this current situation represents a significant opportunity for vertical search engines (VSEs).

Why General Search Engines Fail B2B Professionals

General Internet search engines like Google and Yahoo were not designed to be used as business tools, which is one reason only 4 of 10 professionals surveyed by Convera claim to be "very satisfied" with search results:

  • 11 percent always find what they are looking for on the first attempt.
  • 43 percent always find what they are looking for after several attempts.
  • 21 percent feel their query is always understood.

General search engines rely heavily on the popularity theory that rewards sites with authoritative inbound links. Web site popularity and keyword relevancy (among other variables) help determine rankings. The relevancy model works well for consumer search, as the general population usually finds what it is looking for fairly easy in search results.

For instance, a search for "Toyota Camry" brings up 2,630,000 results on Google and 6,740,000 on Yahoo at the time of this writing. There is no scarcity of information on Google and Yahoo when consumers are looking for product information, and they'll likely find it on the first page.

On the other hand, professionals get a mixed bag. While accustomed to instant success with their personal consumer searches, when it comes to looking up business information it's a different story. According to the Convera study, here's what professionals do when they don't find what they need. As you can see, this group doesn't give up easily:

  • 17 percent give up before 5 minutes.
  • 42 percent continue searching for up to 15 minutes.
  • 24 percent continue searching for up to 30 minutes.
  • 17 percent continue searching for more than 30 minutes.

It seems only logical that if business searches were more efficient and results faster to come by, professionals the Web over would happily employ a different strategy.

The Alternative: VSEs

Instead of fighting the Google and Yahoo wars, B2B firms can get better results by searching for and/or submitting sites to VSEs and directories.

Although these outlets possess only a fraction of the traffic of mass market-oriented search engines, VSEs use customized algorithms and search strings to put relevant results directly in front of targeted B2B buyers in the "hunt mode," or rather individuals actively looking to purchase business-related products and services.

Good VSEs also provide enhanced services such as editorials, custom blogs, and banners. Some will even allow marketers to blog on approved topics, resulting in highly sought-after user-generated content.

New VSEs targeting specific markets, such as the wholesale industry, have arrived in the past two yours. Aside from the benefits for B2B firms, these resources offer options that allow business professionals to tailor searches according to their requirements.

A significant trend revealed by the Convera study is that trade publications are developing their own online vertical search destinations for their professional communities.

When asked about their expectations for these new vertical search resources, nearly 90 percent of professionals say they believe that such search engines will offer more relevant content:

  • 86 percent said VSEs will locate content more quickly.
  • 85 percent believe VSEs will offer access to content not indexed by popular search engines.

Quality, Not Quantity, Makes for a Good VSE

While VSEs can be of great strategic value, businesses should carefully examine all aspects of such services before purchasing. Think of it in terms of selecting a good business partner.

Make sure that the right online community provides the following elements:

  • Industry focus: VSEs, by nature, should be heavily focused on only one industry and maintained by seasoned managers with years of experience in that market. These executives typically know all the potential customers and users of the products and can effectively bring them together in their online community.
  • Free, pertinent content: In the online world, content is king. The more relevant the content, the more attractive the site and the more traffic it drives. VSEs and directories that provide free, objective industry news and information will increase credibility among the target audience. In most cases, these VSEs own trade publications, have partnerships with trade shows, and employ editors to cover all industry aspects.
  • Various interactive features: VSEs should provide the means to solicit feedback and share input with their users. Comment sections on blogs, article submission opportunities, and reciprocal links not only increase a site's prominence but also provide an element of "stickiness." User feedback is critical for fine-tuning site performance. The result is better customer service and an edge on the competition.
  • Numerous, qualified members: While many VSEs claim to service specific markets, you should ensure that their stats add up. Businesses should conduct appropriate due-diligence to validate the amount of qualified traffic and stickiness. Look for case studies that can help you verify the site has the kind of track record that can serve your needs better than other VSEs or general search engines.
  • Results-based marketing services: VSEs should be focused on their customers by offering a wide variety of programs, such as email marketing services, premium ad spaces and banner-ad opportunities designed to reach that special industry audience. Moreover, VSEs should offer well-negotiated rates and a customer service team where account representatives deal one-on-one with each customer—ensuring their unique business goals are well understood.


As evidenced by the results of the aforementioned studies, general search engines are leaving business professionals with much to be desired. Recent developments with VSEs are providing a strong alternative. But, as with any growing industry, it's important to research and understand these alternatives before making the plunge.

The advantages of vertical search will go a long way toward providing professionals with relevant business results while also helping advertisers and marketers target a very specific and relevant audience. Following these guidelines can help navigate this important industry trend.

Join over 600,000 marketing professionals, and gain access to thousands of marketing resources! Don't worry ... it's FREE!


We will never sell or rent your email address to anyone. We value your privacy. (We hate spam as much as you do.) See our privacy policy.

Sign in with one of your preferred accounts below:


Jason A. Prescott is CEO of JP Communications (, a network of wholesale vertical search communities offering search, auctions, advertising networks, and search marketing. He can be reached at

Rate this  

Overall rating

  • This has a 2 star rating
  • This has a 2 star rating
  • This has a 2 star rating
  • This has a 2 star rating
  • This has a 2 star rating
2 rating(s)

Add a Comment


  • by Andy Black Thu Feb 14, 2008 via web

    The E-consultancy/Convera “Vertical Search Survey 2008″ has just been released and reveals some very interesting information. To download a free online copy of the full report, click here

    CPM will be fastest-growing revenue stream for publishers in 2008

    Online revenue set to increase while print income flattens or decreases

    Content owners must ensure visibility within fragmenting digital landscape by embracing RSS, widgets and toolbars.

    Publishers see vertical search as opportunity to ‘reclaim the online community from Google’.

    The fastest-growing revenue streams for publishers in 2008 will be internet display advertising and online sponsorship.

    Some 72% of publishers are expecting an increase in income from CPM advertising next year and 67% are predicting a rise in digital sponsorship, while print revenues are more likely to flatten or decrease. Just under two thirds (64%) are expecting a rise in paid search (PPC) revenue.

    The findings come from a survey which was circulated to members of the Association of Online Publishers (AOP), American Business Media (ABM), Internet Advertising Bureau (IAB UK) and E-consultancy’s early-adopter community of internet marketers.

    The research also highlights the need for specialist publishers to react quickly to major changes in the digital environment in order to maintain and increase their market share and visibility.

    Publishers need to adapt to maximize their digital revenues at a time of shifting advertising budgets. Trends in digital marketing are leading towards a fragmentation of the online landscape and ‘atomization’ of content. Content owners have a great opportunity to increase visibility for their content through the effective use of vertical search, feeds, widgets and toolbars.

    The level of uptake for feeds and customized homepages is very high among this early-adopter audience surveyed but this kind of online behavior will soon become more widespread a

MarketingProfs uses single
sign-on with Facebook, Twitter, Google and others to make subscribing and signing in easier for you. That's it, and nothing more! Rest assured that MarketingProfs: Your data is secure with MarketingProfs SocialSafe!