Become a Member
Guides and Reports
Show All »
Metrics & ROI
Search Engine Marketing
More Marketing Topics »
See All »
Schedule of Events
Virtual Conference Series
Products and Services
Post a Question
Quick Start Guide
Find and Post Jobs
Real-World Education for Modern Marketers
Join Over 603,000 Marketing Professionals
Ask your question ... sign up today! It's FREE!
Just for Fun
MProfs PRO Seminar Q&A
Search more Know-How Exchange Q&A from Marketing Experts
This question has been answered, and points have been awarded.
Is Coupon Magazine Advertising Work
Posted by Anonymous on
9/24/2007 at 4:12 PM ET
I am considering opening a retail store. I am trying to determine my advertising budget. I have come across Val Pak , clipper magazine, other magazines and other coupon mailers. They all seem to guarantee 10000 per zone. My question is : do they work. I would want to sign up for 6 or 12 months. Some will let me change copy every month for the same price.
9/24/2007 at 4:17 PM
You must also consider that advertising with those coupon books creates a certain image about you and what you are.
Don't forget to consider that for the long run, don't just think short term.
9/24/2007 at 4:19 PM
Remember the demographics of your clients. I don't open Value Pak. To me, the thin coupony paper is a turn off and my perception is low end. To some, that feel is appealing.
I get a few higher end magazines-- and that I read. I work with a client here (Local Value) that does 16K and will change copy every month no problem.
I wouldn't sign up for one that wouldn't give you the flexibility to change copy. A key to creating urgency and a reason to respond is making offers timely. Remember everything is negotiable-- including that rate card.
Sell Well and Prosper tm
9/24/2007 at 4:57 PM
Guaranteed impressions means nothing if nobody is impressed enough to buy.
Your local business owners will have better stats than you'll find on this forum. Whoever is selling these coupon packages should be well informed about results. Ask them for testimonials and result statistics from businesses similar to yours. Get contact names, then call those businesses to verify. And call some businesses (from a recent sample package) who were not mentioned to get their take.
SELMARQ Brands' Best Friend
9/24/2007 at 5:16 PM
Val Pak works for some. I recently had this exact discussion with mgoodman, the top "Prof" in this forum, who shared with me that with one of his clients, ValPak has been extremely successful. They divided several coupons to be placed with specific coding and zip codes. They tracked product codes through various seasons and quarters. Over the long period, they developed a sophisticated, successful couponing program.
9/24/2007 at 5:26 PM
Whether they'll work for you, your business, in your community, and with your copy is something only you can judge. As others have mentioned, see what results similar companies have achieved. See if you can split test your copy, color of paper, etc. Track results and incrementally improve (whether you use one of these services or another).
9/24/2007 at 9:03 PM
It depends on your target audience, your market, any seasonality, and a lot of other factors. Most of all it depends on how compelling your copy and offer are.
As Randall said, I had a client experience in which we tested very precisely what we got from each Valpak insertion, each newspaper ad, each Money Mailer, and 5 or 6 other media vehicles (including Advo/Shopwise, missing child cards, etc.).
We had it to the point where we knew the average cost of a new customer from each source each week. We were also able to track the response by day, so we knew the average delay time between the mailing and the response, and we knew how long and how strong the tail was.
In our case, ValPak was much more effective than Money Mailer, but that doesn't mean it will be that way for you. My suggestion would be to do what we did and set up an experimental schedule over, say, 3 months -- and measure everything. If you gang up the efforts at the beginning, you'll be able to apply what you learn over the next 9 months (or even longer). That will make up for any inefficiencies in those first 3 months and then some. It will also minimize any seasonal effects that might otherwise cloud your test.
Let me know if you need more details/specifics.
11/23/2010 at 8:55 PM
debcos: Sounds like you are the owner of the business "suppliers and contacts"
BACK TO TOP
Post a Comment
Top Five Questions Marketers Should Always Be Asking Themselves
by Preeti Upadhyaya
Five Tips for Effective 'Emotional Branding'
by Jeannette de Beauvoir
Why Your Data Scientists Need to Be Storytellers, and How to Get ...
by Laura Patterson
10 Tactics to Increase Newsletter Subscriptions
by Aleksander Czyz
2015 Marketing and Advertising Salary Guide
by Ayaz Nanji
See more marketing articles »
MarketingProfs uses single
sign-on with Facebook, Twitter, Google and others to make subscribing and signing in easier for you. That's it, and nothing more! Rest assured that
provide your social data to 3rd parties
contact friends on your network
post messages on your behalf
interact with your social accounts
Your data is secure with