Did you happen to see the last episode of The Apprentice? Two teams of celebrity contestants were asked to create a campaign to help launch a new product, Dial Yogurt Body Wash. The task was to come up with a four-page advertorial for Redbook Magazine.
Both teams sat down with execs from Dial and Redbook to discuss the product and the target audience (including Redbook's readership). They were then given access to exceptional photographers and set designers.
Each team took a different approach. Team one featured a member of the team, model Carol Alt, who had already been on the cover of Redbook five times. Its ads showed beautiful photos of Carol using the product in very staged settings—alone, shot one; with a baby, shot two, etc. It ended with what was termed an "edgy" photo of Carol in bed with a man looking as if he's about to bite her (not sexy or appealing, in my subjective view!).
Other than the final page, the ad copy and photos were all safe, predictable, and typical. Just like other ads you'd expect in Redbook.
Team two decided to feature a team member, as well: country star Trace Adkins. A heated dispute among associates focused on which final photos to use: a shirtless, provocative photo of Trace pictured with two other shirtless men, or a photo of Trace playing guitar next to a woman taking a bath (seemingly using Yogurt Body Wash).
The first team (with the exception of the final bedroom shot) was given glowing reviews by the judges, including the Donald, Ivanka, and George. Yadda. Yadda. Yadda.
Am I the only one who thinks all this screamed of mediocrity?
Here's what they seemed to miss:
Kathy Parsanko is a storytelling marketing consultant in Cincinnati, Ohio. She can be reached at Kathyjo@fuse.net.