Real-World Education for Modern Marketers

Join Over 600,000 Marketing Professionals

Start here!
Text:  A A

Why 70% of Facebook 'Fans' Don't Want Marketing, and What You Can Do About It

by   |    |  11,213 views

This summer, I directed research on consumers' attitudes toward marketing. We surveyed more than 2,300 consumers and interviewed nearly 100 people on the street.

Among our findings was that 70% of consumers who visit Facebook at least once a month and are a "fan" of at least one company or brand don't believe they have given those companies permission to market to them. Moreover, 40% of those "fans" don't believe marketers are welcome in social networks at all.

Getting people to identify themselves as fans is obviously a good thing, but what is the value if consumers don't believe they are kindling a relationship with marketers when doing so?

The following insights from the study* will help you understand how companies can capitalize on this demonstration of enthusiasm without turning fans off.

Consider the environment

People visit social networks to communicate with current friends, catch up with old friends, and otherwise express themselves.

A full 44% of people who are fans of at least one company or brand on Facebook also say social networks should be used strictly for interpersonal communication.

They don't believe marketers are welcome. To them, self-identification as a fan is not an invitation; it is an expression of personal taste or style intended to be shared primarily with friends.

Remember preppies? They identified themselves by sporting the Polo logo. They were not asking Polo to advertise to them;, rather, they were inadvertently marketing for Polo. Don't overlook the fact that by creating the space for consumers to share their enthusiasm you are creating a platform where their endorsement is itself marketing.

Don't act like "marketers"

The core message is simple. Warranted or not, "marketer" has become a derogatory term in the minds of most consumers. Consumers don't trust marketing. Consumers trust people (or brands) that help them and exhibit interests similar to theirs.

Marketers' first inclination is to build a fan base so that they can send those people marketing messages. Even when promoted as "exclusively for our fans," that approach is similar to other direct-marketing tactics; unless offers are truly unique, consumers are increasingly put off by such offers.

Align with fans instead of selling to them

Anything that demonstrates the alignment of your interests as a brand with the interests of your consumers can constitute a meaningful brand experience.

Consider TripAdvisor's "More than Footprints" campaign, which promised to distribute $1 million across five preselected nonprofit organizations according to how members voted.

The campaign netted TripAdvisor 500,000 new members, measurably improved members' overall impressions of the brand, and generated extensive press coverage. Remove the goodwill, tax write-off, and press coverage, and the campaign was still a huge success at a $2 cost per new member—all by figuring out how to energize TripAdvisor's existing community.

Be quick to listen and slow to speak

When it comes to positive comments, let your fans tell the story for you.

However, there are also negative comments. They come in two forms: those you can address in a helpful way (e.g., "I went to the store, and they couldn't help me...") and those you can't (e.g., "You suck").

Don't engage unless you can be helpful, but choose to engage in real-world dialogue and problem-solving. That allows your brand to demonstrate its relational prowess in a public forum—which, in turn, can create raving fans. When you impress your fans by handling their issues, you give them additional ammunition to act as your advocate.

In addition, listening helps identify opportunities for improvements to your products or services. Develop a system for capturing those and allow your customer to see that you are listening.

(For example, ExactTarget has instituted a system allowing customers to vote on other users' product suggestions; those with the most votes quickly become priorities on the product road map.)

Direct consumers to other channels for marketing messages

Comparing data from this year with data collected in 2008, we see consumers' attitudes toward nonpermission (or "pushy") marketing messages souring fast. However, that isn't true for permission-based messages; consumers are very receptive to promotions and are reporting using coupons more often.

In marketer-initiated communications, email is the preferred channel (75% of consumers overall), even among teens (64%) and college students (70%). Consumers prefer to maintain a church-and-state separation between how they communicate with friends and how they receive deals from the brands they follow.

Use what you learn to improve marketing across the board

Marketers have two clear opportunities to leverage data gathered through social media to improve the performance of other marketing channels.

First, fans' sentiments can provide crucial insight into what is and isn't resonating with audiences—allowing marketers to adjust their messaging through other channels accordingly. Positive aspects of the brand can be highlighted, and common issues or misconceptions can be addressed proactively.

Second, by identifying email subscribers (or subscribers to other channels, such as direct mail or text messages) as Facebook fans, marketers are able to better target and communicate with them as members of this highly motivated and engaged audience.

That communication may involve addressing hot topics being discussed by fans on your Wall, highlighting additional social experiences that may be of interest, or asking this proactive group to rate and review products on your website.

* * *

Consumers' expectations in social-media environments are fundamentally different from their expectations of other direct-marketing channels. Approach social media with that difference in mind. To succeed, marketers need to overcome considerable skepticism on the part of their consumers.

Of course, there are exceptions. Apple, for example, includes promotions on its Apple Students fan page. However, Apple has already developed a reputation for being a company that listens and engages. That type of reputation takes time to develop, but once it's in place customers see your marketing differently—in fact, they won't even think of it as marketing; they come to think of it as an extension of your service.

If consumers are to change their minds about marketers' being welcome on Facebook or other social networks, it will be because marketers interact as participants in the dialogue instead of attempting to control the dialogue through slick messaging.

It's not that marketers can't launch social-media campaigns; rather, they can't act and think like marketers when doing so. They must create meaningful brand experiences that are focused on service, and they must be so well aligned with fans that fans don't even realize they are being marketed to.

*For more, download Customer Knowledge Is Marketer Power, a commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting, and the 2009 Channel Preference Study, at

Join over 600,000 marketing professionals, and gain access to thousands of marketing resources! Don't worry ... it's FREE!


We will never sell or rent your email address to anyone. We value your privacy. (We hate spam as much as you do.) See our privacy policy.

Sign in with one of your preferred accounts below:

Morgan Stewart is co-founder and CEO of Trendline Interactive (, a strategic email marketing agency.

Rate this  

Overall rating

  • This has a 4 star rating
  • This has a 4 star rating
  • This has a 4 star rating
  • This has a 4 star rating
  • This has a 4 star rating
3 rating(s)

Add a Comment


  • by Patrick Zuluaga, PMZ Marketing Tue Nov 10, 2009 via web

    It is a challenging one isn't it? As marketeers we have to respect the expectations of users on the social networks while giving them the opportunity to express their points of view in relation to your brand while contributing positively to the engagement and interaction. This I think is the key giving opportunity to express views and engage with those views.

  • by Anne Marsden Tue Nov 10, 2009 via web

    So true - good set of things to keep in mind when trying to engage with Fans - When a brand acts more like an individual - with cool info to share, stories, photos, life experiences, funny circumstances - then the brand begins to be perceived as a Friend" not a company with Fans. One of our clients recently began developing their Facebook persona and has seen rapid increases in their Fan base. As a portrait photographer, Fletcher Portrait Artist, shares experiences, travel logs, encounters with celebrities, etc. in a way that is personal and interesting...rather than selling/promoting - and it paid off exactly as you talk about here. they are seeing the results very much like you

  • by Gabe Casalett Wed Nov 11, 2009 via web

    The timing of this article is very interesting to me. I was just at Ad:tech New York last week and Facebook had a huge, fancy booth showing off their advertising services. Facebook wants to be the next marketing media, and they are working hard at recruiting marketers. I think it won't be long before becoming a 'fan' of a company requires you to opt in/out of an email newsletter.

  • by AgencyNet Wed Nov 11, 2009 via web

    Great Article. I especially agree with points 1 and 2. In order for a brand to be successful on Facebook or any other social network for that matter, they need to first understand the space. As mentioned in this post, Facebook is about connecting with friends and often an outlet for people to express themselves, not to feel like they’re at a used car lot being hassled by a sales man.

    Marketers can avoid the “sales man” stereotype if they find ways to add value. I recently participated in a research at my office to see how people in my agency obtained information. While the majority (67%) said they found most of their information from RSS and Blogs, the second largest group at 55% said they sought out information through social networks like Twitter and Facebook. That’s pretty powerful stuff!

    Listening is key here. Find out what people are talking about. Not just about your brand, but what people are talking about as a whole. Find out how your brand can fill a void or answer a question using your expertise and knowledge as the base. Betty Cocker ( actually did a fantastic job with this same strategy. They found that an overwhelming amount of people were searching for ways to bake cakes. Cocker saw the opportunity and instead of selling the brand, they created cake making videos that utilized the brand’s knowledge and product, all the while filling a void without acting as a sales man. A great win for Betty, for sure!

    Adam Lauer | AgencyNet

  • by Michael Hollon Thu Nov 12, 2009 via web

    Using social media for sending marketing messages presents not only some formitable challenges as the above article explained, but it also presents marketers with a much more powerful and effective tool than they've ever had. Marketers need to get beyond the defensive stance that consumers are forced to take in the face of relentless traditional marketing methods. Imagine a legion of brand apostiles who only are vaguely aware they've been enlisted to work for you.

  • by Paul McKeon Thu Nov 12, 2009 via web

    We are who we trust. Consumers are defining themselves by the products and services they endorse, whether they become a Facebook fan, wear a logo, or forward a white paper to a colleague. To get those endorsements, marketers must become trusted, and they can't afford to be sneaky about it. Post-credit-meltdown, consumers are ever more skeptical and don't offer their trust lightly to the brands they endorse. So, social media requires marketers to earn that trust by being generous, and to cut the ties between their communications and the pitch. Market leadership happens when the followers choose to trust the leader.

    I disagree with @Gabe that Facebook's model will change to opt-in, unless Facebook gets greedy and makes a short-sighted mistake. The rewards of endorsements, and allowing marketers to build credibility and leadership are too great. The challenge is that those rewards aren't as tangible as some marketing managers would like. The marketers who see past that challenge will prevail.

    Agree with @Michael Hollon that marketers need to break away from the defensive stance. Holding information close to the vest doesn't play in the open social media/thought leadership world we live in.

    I've been blogging recently about Thought Leadership in B2B marketing, and the principles are the same as on Facebook.

  • by Dave Hamel Tue Nov 17, 2009 via web

    Yet a recent study says many consumers will use Social Media sites for comparison shopping. What's a marketer to do?

  • by Marita Greenidge Wed Nov 25, 2009 via web

    Great article. I've recently started a marketing consulting firm in Barbados and social media makes up part of the marketing toolkit I suggest to clients. This information will be very useful for determining which content goes through which channels. In fact I'll recommend that my clients read it.

  • by Nikhil Thu Mar 29, 2012 via web

    Hey Morgan,

    Great post - and very relevant too, what with marketing and business and 'social' all in a state of perpetual flux since the advent of FB and its cousins. Very useful to me personally. Thanks a lot!

MarketingProfs uses single
sign-on with Facebook, Twitter, Google and others to make subscribing and signing in easier for you. That's it, and nothing more! Rest assured that MarketingProfs: Your data is secure with MarketingProfs SocialSafe!