Become a Member
Guides and Reports
Show All »
Metrics & ROI
Search Engine Marketing
More Marketing Topics »
See All »
Schedule of Events
Virtual Conference Series
Products and Services
Post a Question
Quick Start Guide
Find and Post Jobs
Real-World Education for Modern Marketers
Join Over 613,000 Marketing Professionals
Ask your question ... sign up today! It's FREE!
Just for Fun
MProfs PRO Seminar Q&A
Search more Know-How Exchange Q&A from Marketing Experts
This question has been answered, and points have been awarded.
Comparison Between Brand Image And Brand Identity
Posted by Anonymous on
4/21/2005 at 3:16 AM ET
I am an MBA student. I am doing my summer training in Industrial Development Bank Of India Ltd. IDBIL is going through a very crucial phase now. Idbi, one of biggest and oldest DFIs in india which helped setting up many companies and other financial entities, thus building the nation ,have merged with idbi bank and is now known as IDBI LTD.
I am asked by my project guide in IDBIL to compare the brand identity and brand image of IDBIL.
my question is: 1) How should I frame the objective.
Should it be a hypothesis testing like
Null hypothesis: There is no significant difference between brand identity and brand image of IDBIL.
Alternate Hypothesis: there exists significant difference between brand identity and brand image of IDBIL.
2) How about the sampling. should I interview both employees and customers?
3) should I use two different set of questionnaires for each of them or can I rely on secondary data to identify the brand identity?
4) since my study spans only for two months( this study is as part of the course requirement) I am thinking of using a questionnaire.Is perceptual mapping sufficient for the study? what about using Young and Rubicam's brand asset evaluator or Aaker's brand personality list or should I start from scratch by identifying associations.
I am in real confusion. Hope some one would help.
4/21/2005 at 8:30 AM
Your question should be in the students section but I will try and be helpful where relevant.
The Brand Identity is a set of unique attributes/associations that the company creates. These associations represent what the brand should stand for and imply a potential promise to customers. The brand identity is helped by actively managing every brand contact point with customers ensuring everything is aligned consistently.
The brand identity should refer to the strategic goal for a brand while the Brand Image is what customers actually perceive in their minds.
1 & 2) Talking to both company employees and customers will help you find the gaps between what the company thinks it's brand identity is and what their customers actually perceive in reality. You can do this both through survey and questionnaire.
You ideally need to talk to all stakeholders - i.e most companies will have shareholders, customers or buyers, consumers, users, employees and suppliers. Each stakeholder will have a different perspective because their needs will be different. Identifying the channels the company uses to communicate with all stakeholders to promote their brand should also be considered.
3) Start with identifying attributes/associations. Collate first and secondary data for the identity. A brand positioning statement (BPS - i.e. Why should customers buy our brand over competitors?) will help you get to facts and get started. Your BPS is a one page summary of key elements which make up your brand propsition and brand personality. The BPS should be updated every year so check for last years if they have one, it could be helpful.
4) Y&R's & Dr Aaker's tool s will both help. Use the tools you feel are relevant in achieving your objective. You could also delve into conducting a Customer Brand Loyalty check for more meat.
I think you can go from here on your own. Hope this helps.
4/21/2005 at 9:50 AM
I will try to focus on the stats portion of your question. The primary problem or confusion I see is that your hypothesis test lacks focus and definition.
For instance, the very fact you have to ask whether you will question employees and customers gives me that perception. In addition, the term ‘significant difference’ without a mathematical expression gives me the same perception.
I would also spend some time clearly defining what aspects of brand identity and brand image will be focused on so you can create a set of questions to help with the survey and the mathematical results from the answers.
I believe, in general, your null and alternative will work but you need to think of this as comparing P0 and P1 rather then against a parameter since you are testing two different objects and then trying to figure our if there are ‘significant difference’ in the perceptions of these two objects.
Given you stated you only have two months, the more you define now the better off you will be.
Hope that helps.
4/26/2005 at 6:30 AM
In a nutshell…
Brand image is perception, The perception of How you communicate, the environments in which you trade, the responsibilities both social and economic, your ethics, your products and services and behaviour… and so it goes on
Brand identity is the visual means by which the above is communicated. At the core of this is your logo, letterhead, printed literature, livery, annual reports, products, packaging, and so it goes on.
A logo alone does not make a brand, in the same way a suite does not make a businessman, his character and personality is his brand (personality).
Hope this helps a little to wade through all the waffle that is out there.
5/14/2005 at 11:43 AM
Brand Identity is aspirational, it's where you want your brand to be in the minds of your customers. Brand image is how the brand is perceived by your customers at a particular moment. A great reference is David Aacker's "Brand Leadership". He says that "Brand image is tactical--an element that drives short-term results and can be comfortably left to advertising and promotion specialists."
What you should be looking at is IDBIL's current brand equity which is the combination of brand awareness, perceived quality, brand associations, and brand loyalty and its brand identity which is an internal statement of where you want the brand to be which should be linked to their overall business strategy (something you may be able to gleam from talking to senior people within the organization and from the mission and vision statements).
An example from Aaker's book. Volvo's brand equity is its "strong reputation for safety, quality, and care for the environment" while it's identity summary is "style, driving pleasure and superior ownership experience while celebrating human values and respecting the environment". See how one is where the brand is while the other is where you want the brand to be.
Aaker's web site is
but I do suggest you get the book, it's really helpful and surprisingly agood read.
5/18/2005 at 5:16 PM
Hello all. I am closing this question since it's more than 2 weeks old. We do this to reward the contributions of participants in a timely manner + to give increased visibility to the newer questions.
Thanks for participating!
Carrie (Production Editor)
BACK TO TOP
Post a Comment
What the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge Can Teach Us About Content ...
by Lauren Covello
How to Close the Gap Between Sales and Marketing
by David Meerman Scott
Marketing Ops Is Now a Must-Have: The Six A's of Marketing ...
by Laura Patterson
Do You Understand the Email Halo Effect?
by Dela Quist
How to Be the Worst Email Marketer in 10 Easy Steps
by Karol Król
See more marketing articles »
MarketingProfs uses single
sign-on with Facebook, Twitter, Google and others to make subscribing and signing in easier for you. That's it, and nothing more! Rest assured that
provide your social data to 3rd parties
contact friends on your network
post messages on your behalf
interact with your social accounts
Your data is secure with