Question

Topic: Other

Communication Process Problems

Posted by Anonymous on 2750 Points
Hi There,

Can someone discuss the problems communication breakdowns can cause in the context of the relationship between marketing teams and advertising agencies?

Could you also identify methods of overcoming these communication breakdowns between the marketing teams and advertising agencies?

Please Please Help :-D
To continue reading this question and the solution, sign up ... it's free!

RESPONSES

  • Posted on Member
    Hi Piper. It sounds to me like you are asking us to do your homework assignment for you. This is not the purpose of Marketing Profs forum. After all, you want to leave school with the ability to solve problems. That being said, I can give you some guidance.

    Anytime you have a large organization, it is necessary to have processes in place to ensure that communications are clear and understood. Ever notice how many restaurants have the waiter read back your order for you? This is to ensure clarity. When it comes to communicating with vendors (the agencies in your example) processes can be set up to ensure clarity. Anyway, this should lead you in the right direction. Take it from here and do some research about communications. Think about the nature of the marketing team - ad agency relationship.

    Good luck,

    Alexa
  • Posted on Member
    Please assure us that this isn't a homework assignment.

    I have actually worked on projects to help clients get better advertising from their agencies, and I've worked with agencies to help them get better direction from their clients.

    The solution to both is with a tight Creative Brief that forces the client to define the critical criteria for good advertising BEFORE the agency begins its work.

    I could go on for a long time on the advantages of using a Creative Brief. If you want more information, check out this page from the website of a real advertising professional (and former client, and colleague).

    Good luck. If this IS a homework assignment, you'll get an A+ on it now.
  • Posted on Author
    Hi There,

    This is not a homework assignment.

    My Boss has asked me to put together a power point presentation with notes to discuss the importance of communication. Our marketing team are meeting with several agencies who will be pitching for our business and my manager wants to ensure that the team are aware of problems which may arrise in the communication process and the effects this may have on the marketing team / advertising agencies relationship

    Many Thanks

  • Posted by Jay Hamilton-Roth on Accepted
    Two main issues: 1) Will they do what you want and 2) Do they know what it takes to produce results?

    1) Requires a creative brief to define what you want, and you'll want quick turnaround of options to ensure they understand your goals (i.e., place a limit on how long they work until they produce some prototypes/sketches).

    2) You want more than someone who can take your idea and bring it to fruition - you want someone who understands what works and doesn't. You want a partner who can make suggestions to your ideas, with concrete rationale for these ideas.
  • Posted on Accepted
    Marketing teams have different tasks to perform than advertising teams, and thus both of them need to be briefed accordingly.

    Larger companies usually develop a protocol or even a process to ensure that these briefs are correctly and comprehensively given.

    A marketing brief will consist or sales, penetration, market and brand share goals and targets with profitability, productivity, demographic, geographical and brand positioning parameters.

    This is too broad for an advertising brief and can be easily be misinterpreted as the advertising team will not have the other end of the information required – the organisational history and the resources and limitations with which the marketing team will have to work.

    A good marketing team will translate this into an advertising brief which will define communications goals, what behaviour they must influence, what changes they must bring about.

    It will define the target audience and the marketing team’s interpretation of the utilitarian and emotional needs that must be addressed. Both demographics and psychographics will be defined.

    It will define the brand proposition and the brand promise, and define the personality of the brand.

    If possible it should also lay down clear, quantifiable success and failure criteria.

    I hope this answers your question. Good luck!


  • Posted by terrikennedy777 on Accepted
    The best thing to remember when you have an agency is after you've finished the plan and signed off on all the creative briefs is that they are living documents just as your business is a living business. You are living it everyday for 8 (or 10 or 12 hours) each day.

    Your agency has only the luxury of whatever time and input you give them. So they learn of the changes only as you feed them. What you have grown to understand over a week or two is often dropped on them in a phone call.

    Simply recognizing that we (I have always lived on the company side) live in the 'drink in the changes slowly world' and our agencies live in the 'catch up quick as the earth has shifted while you weren't looking' world, goes a long way to keeping us in check when the communications are breaking down.

    I realize this is a bit subjective when working to put factors into a contract, but for me communcations and relationship success are inextricably linked and never have anything to do with a contract.

    I hope this helps!
    Terri Kennedy
  • Posted on Author
    Hi There,

    Thank you all very much for your help, your advice has been invaluable.

    Kindest Regards

    Kelly

Post a Comment