Question

Topic: Advertising/PR

Ad Contractors Matching Serv. In Women's Magazine

Posted by Anonymous on 250 Points
Hi pros,
Yesterday I was approach by woman's magazine to advertise my contractors referral business with them.
1. Is it a good place for my business to be advertise?
2. If it is so, what major benefit would be the best to address in the ad?
To get a better idea of services you can visit www.forhomeowner.com Your advice on website improvement is very welcome, it's a "rough draft", I don't promote it widely.
The dead line for ad is very close, I'd appreciate your quick respond.
Cheers, Igor
To continue reading this question and the solution, sign up ... it's free!

RESPONSES

  • Posted on Moderator
    Who is your target audience? Does it match the magazine's reader profile?

    Where do you get most of your customers now? What's the average cost per new customer? What's your call to action, and how will you know if the ad is really generating any new business for you?

    You need to ask those questions (of yourself) before you spend your money on advertising in the magazine. If the cost of advertising looks attractive, and if the magazine's readers are truly your target audience, it might be worth a test.

    Of course, the key to success with any advertising is great copy. If your ad is lousy, it doesn't matter what the medium is.

    As for your website, you probably need to make it more obvious what the benefit is. Why should someone call you? What important and unique benefitn do you provide? That needs to be front and center. And you need a clear and specific call to action.

    And, if you can narrow your audience focus, that would be good. Who are your best customers? You'll be better served trying to get 100% of a narrow target audience than 0.00001% of a huge one.

    If you only serve Edmonton, say so. If you also serve Calgary, say so. The more specific you can be, the more relevant your advertising will be to your primary target audience.

    Hope this helps.
  • Posted by Chris Blackman on Member
    I completely support what mgoodman says above.

    You will always get these "unrepeatable" offers. Fact is, they get repeated every time the publication is short of revenue or a major advertiser fails to deliver material for a pre-booked position in the publication.

    If I was you, I would pass on this offer.

    Here's why:

    1. Your website isn't ready.
    2. You don't have a clear value proposition - at least, not one that is explicit via your website.
    3. It's just a sales pitch. Don't fall for it.

    How could you better invest the money you were contemplating spending on Edmonton Woman?

    * Do you have a business plan?
    * A marketing plan?
    * Did your marketing plan involve ever advertising in Edmonton Woman?

    If not, don't even think about it, no matter how cheap a deal it may seem to be.

    Instead, find out more about your target customers. Find out what they read, watch or listen to. then work out how to reach them effectively through their favourite medium.

    Because once you start advertising, all advertising sales people will be knocking on your door. And you can simply tell them "you're not on our media plan, thank you."

    Never get sidetracked by a bargain - no matter how good it may seem. If it's not in your strategic plan, it's the "opposite of strategic" [TM].


  • Posted by CarolBlaha on Member
    You just have to decide if this group is your demographics. I'd ask for a trial and major discount. Keep it on a short leash. If it doesn't work-- stop doing it.
  • Posted by Jay Hamilton-Roth on Member
    Before you place an ad, get a bunch of testimonials from happy customers first (ideally, with photos of those happy customers and the completed job). That's what people are wanting: confirmation that the price was great and see for themselves how wonderful it was.
  • Posted by Chris Blackman on Accepted
    Igor, I sense your impatience to get going DOING something but without a plan your DOING will come at a high price - you'll be paying for experimentation, rather than paying for thinking things through. THINKING and PLANNING before DOING which is always going to be cheaper.

    I have an idea for you that will cost you next to nothing and will allow you to do some testing: Approach several of the major biog-box renovator/hardware stores and offer them a supply of business cards for people who want to buy 'stuff' but have no tradespeople to do the installation work.

    That takes you right to the point where the rubber meets the road. You'll have people who are on the verge of spending and who need your directional input to find tradespeople right there and then.

    Magazine readers aren't doers, not yet... They are still the dreamers - you want people ready to buy. Those people are already looking for the fixtures and fittings, and wondering about how to take the next step.

    Based on how that works out, THEN DO YOUR PLAN!

    Over to you...

Post a Comment